Writing in the disciplines pdf

Teachers comment primarily on the substance of these assignments, but teachers also expect students to meet professional standards of layout and proofreading format and mechanical correctness. Without doubt, the single most important reason for assigning writing tasks in disciplinary courses is to introduce students to the thinking and writing of that discipline.

Even though students read disciplinary texts and learn course material, until they practice the language of the discipline through writing, they are less likely to learn that language thoroughly. In addition, teachers cite other specific advantages of WID tasks, large and small. Such writing helps students to:. Teachers need to decide which goals are most important for them and for the students they typically teach. For instance, if you ordinarily teach a freshman-level survey course that introduces students to the field, giving students practice in the conventions of writing for that field is generally inappropriate.

Rather, you would probably want to give students opportunities to write about the new, foundational concepts they're being introduced to so that you can be sure they are learning the fundamental ideas they will need to take other courses in your discipline. Teachers thinking about assigning writing in their courses also need to consider just how much time they'll have to review or respond to student writing.

Assigning a page term paper in a course with students is unrealistic because teachers seldom have time to read and respond to such lengthy student writing. As teachers determine goals for writing and their time commitment, they discover an entire spectrum of writing they might assign in their classes.

You will base your decisions on complex factors, but the simplified grid below can point you toward additional materials that might be most useful to you as you plan your writing component for each class. Although the research essay is the most common kind of WID assignment, it's not the only format that students can use to learn about disciplinary writing conventions. If professionals in your field use any of these types of writing, consider using these formats to help students understand the thinking and writing of your discipline:.

In addition to discipline-specific formats, other kinds of writing assignments can help students learn the language and ways of thinking of a discipline, even though they may not mimic its professional writing. In a discipline-specific context, teachers using a reading journal ask students to write summaries, responses, and syntheses as appropriate for the field. Teachers might want to assign specific questions to be answered in entries about each reading, or they might link readings in other ways.

When you introduce new terms in your lectures or when students see them in readings, ask students to jot the terms down in a notebook or electronic file. Periodically, students then return to the list of terms and fill in or revise working definitions of each term. Some terms will be easy to define immediately after they are introduced in a course; other terms might take more familiarity with the complexity of a concept to define accurately. Build in some incentive for keeping the jargon journal by pointing out that students can refer to the definitions as they prepare for—and perhaps write—exam responses.

In addition to analyzing articles for content, as students might do in the reading journal, teachers can also ask students to look specifically at professional articles for rhetorical issues:.

Small-group or full-class discussion of these analyses will help students understand the critical approaches professionals in the field typically adopt as well as the writing conventions accepted by major journals in the field.

Bring in drafts of your own work or of someone else's professional work that you have permission to share with students. Show students:. Because the popular article is written to a general audience with little specialized knowledge, teachers often assign this writing task to be sure students understand material well enough to explain it in non-technical terms.

If you're concerned about assigning a full-length article, you could assign this task as a group writing project, with different group members responsible for chunks of the final article. Or you might just assign the introduction and an outline for key ideas that would go into the remainder of the article. One reason that students report feeling overwhelmed by WID tasks is that they aren't sure where to start and then how to proceed to produce a good project of the sort required by the assignment.

You can help students—and get better final drafts to read—by setting up a sequence of tasks that build toward the final project. When professors are reluctant to assign research essays, they often claim that students cannot write clearly and logically, synthesizing sources and evaluating data to draw closely argued conclusions. Most often, these weaknesses are not the result simply of poor writing skills, but also of poorly defined criteria that students don't grasp.

Fortunately, teachers can improve the research essay by clarifying goals for the assignment and keeping students' resources in mind. Most university professors agree that research-based writing in college classes can and should meet these goals:. Students often view the research-based paper as an exercise in cutting and pasting rather than in carefully sifting and synthesizing key ideas that support their own thinking. So teachers get the best results from research-based assignments that they have revised after considering these questions:.

If you've decided that a traditional research essay best meets your teaching goals, please consider three ideas that might make this assignment more useful for students:. Most students in upper-level courses and even most freshmen know how to find general sources. But many upper-division students may not yet be familiar with specific sources in your discipline. Make sure they know how to find these, and even consider arranging a session in the library to go over search techniques for databases in your field.

Students are remarkably reluctant to admit they have a hard time reading research-based texts. But if they don't know how to read professional articles in your field, they certainly won't know how to evaluate the data and conclusions in those articles.

The Ag Econ assignment is a good example of breaking down a larger writing task so that the teacher can see if students need help with key elements of the larger writing task. If students, for example, don't know how to frame an adequate research question, you can head off this problem if you give students a mini-task that asks for a research question long before students begin their source work.

Similarly, if your experience with this course in the past suggests that students often struggle to analyze or synthesize data, you might want to set up sequenced writing tasks that give them some practice—and feedback—on these key writing skills. The literature now available on writing in the disciplines or writing to communicate is deep and broad, encompassing far more than a brief bibliographic essay can accurately capture.

Let me offer instead two pieces of advice—consult the general resources noted here and look at the journals in your discipline that take up teaching issues. Those journals are most likely to include articles that situate writing to communicate activities in the courses you might find yourself teaching.

The articles themselves will glean from the robust resources to point you toward those titles that will best fill in background you might find helpful. We collect below titles from across disciplines to offer some potential starting points. We have organized the resources in a table to cluster articles by discipline. Please note, however, that disciplinary titles here point to writing in the disciplines rather than writing to learn or writing to engage titles that are included in the WTL section of this resource.

All titles refer to the list of Works Cited that follows the tables. Abbate-Vaughn, J. The graduate writing challenge: A perspective from an urban teacher education program. Action in Teacher Education, 29 2 , Addams, L. Developing student communication skills while assisting nonprofit organizations. Business Communication Quarterly, 73 3 , Allwardt, D. Writing with wikis: A cautionary tale of technology in the classroom.

Journal of Social Work Education, 47 3 , Bahls, P. Student writing in the quantitative disciplines: A guide for college faculty. Indianapolis, IN: Jossey Bass. Bank, C. Reading and writing taught in a sophomore course on plate tectonics. Journal of Geoscience Education, 54 1 , Becker, S. Guest comment: Teaching writing to teach physics. American Journal of Physics, 63 7 , Beiersdorfer, R. An integrated approach to geologic writing for non-science majors based on study of a California river.

Journal of Geological Education, 39 : Beins, B. Writing assignments in statistics classes encourage students to learn interpretation. Teaching of Psychology, 20 3 , Blevins-Knabe, B. Writing to learn while learning to write. Teaching of Psychology, 14 4 , Bourelle, T. Bridging the gap between the technical communication classroom and the internship: Teaching social consciousness and real-world writing.

Journal of Technical Writing and Communication, 42 2 , Bressette, A. Using writing to enhance the undergraduate research experience.

Journal of Chemical Education, 78 12 , Brumberger, E. The "corporate correspondence project": Fostering audience awareness and extended collaboration. Business Communication Quarterly, 67 3 , Buddington, A. A field-based, writing intensive undergraduate course on. Buzzi, O. Writing for the discipline in the discipline? Teaching in Higher Education, 17 4 , Carlson, J. Using undergraduate journals and peer pressure to improve undergraduate writing in economics.

The Journal of Economics, 24 2 , Carlson, P. Using computer-mediated peer review in an engineering design course. Carroll, F. Placing science into its human context: Using scientific autobiography to teach chemistry. Carson, R. Land-use-planning writing assignment for an environment-geology course.

Carter, M. Writing to learn by learning to write in the disciplines. Journal of Business and Technical Communication, 21 3 , Cass, A. Simulated conference submissions: A technique to improve student attitudes about writing. Centellas, M. PS: Political Science and Politics, 43 3 , Chamely,Wiik, D. From Bhopal to cold fusion: A case-study approach to writing assignments in honors general chemistry.

Journal of Chemical Education, 89 4 , Cheng, C. Assessing the effectiveness of a voluntary online discussion forum on improving students' course performance. Chiang, C. Learning Chronobiology by improving Wikipedia. Journal of Biological Rhythms, 27 4 , Colabroy, K.

A writing-intensive, methods-based laboratory course for undergraduates. Collins, J. Engineers learn to write: Coaching the art of noticing with writing samples. Conrad, S. Balancing teaching and learning geology on the writing fulcrum.

Craig, J. Innovation across the curriculum: Three case studies in teaching science and engineering communication. Crisp, K. Pros and cons of a group webpage design project in a freshman anatomy and physiology course. Advances in Physiology Education, 31 4 , Cunningham, K. Applications of reaction rate. Journal of Chemical Education, 84 3 , Davis, L. Student abstract writing as a tool for writing across the curriculum in large introductory-geology courses.

Deese, W. Using demonstration assessments to improve writing. Journal of Chemical Education, 77 11 , DeWolf, J. Incorporation of writing into a steel design course. Dickovick, J. Methods in the madness: Integrative approaches to methodology in introductory comparative politics. Journal of Political Science Education, 5 2 , Doty, L.

A mathematician learns the basics of writing instruction: An immersion experience with long-term benefits. Primus, 22 1 , Elberty, W. Journal of geological education, 39 : Every academic discipline has its own writing requirements. While all formal academic writing shares some common attributes, there are often differences in style and format.

For example, all disciplines want audience appropriate, grammatically correct writing. A concise introduction to some of the basic conventions of writing in English. Brief Guide to Writing the Psychology Paper. A concise introduction to some of the basic conventions of writing in psychology.

Skip to main content. Main Menu Utility Menu Search. Contact Us.